…..Invitation is Highly Troubling….Right Group President Muhammadu Buhari has said that a strong and effective International Criminal Court (ICC) is a catalyst for justice even as his invitation has drawn the ire of right groups who argue that it is “inappropriate”. It was also his view that “the ICC has given hope for justice to
…..Invitation is Highly Troubling….Right Group
President Muhammadu Buhari has said that a strong and effective International Criminal Court (ICC) is a catalyst for justice even as his invitation has drawn the ire of right groups who argue that it is “inappropriate”. It was also his view that “the ICC has given hope for justice to so many by demanding strict adherence to the rules of international humanitarian law” “
“A strong and effective ICC can also act as a catalyst for other justice efforts, expanding the reach of accountability. These could include serious cases of corruption by state actors that severely compromise the development efforts of countries and throw citizens into greater poverty”, the President said.
Delivering a keynote address at The Hague, Netherlands as guest at the event marking the 20th anniversary of the ICC, Buhari argued that “A strong and effective ICC has the potential to send a powerful message about the international community’s commitment to accountability, a message that will be heard by both victims and perpetrators. Equally, a strong and effective ICC demonstrates the international community’s commitment to the rule of law”.
“With the alarming proliferation of the most serious crimes around the world, the ICC, and all that it stands for, is now needed more than ever, in ways that were unforeseeable to its founders. The ICC may have been created at a time of optimism that it would not need to be utilized frequently, but, unfortunately, the increase in international crimes has only increased the Court’s relevance”, he said.
“As the African Union Champion on Anti-corruption, these are issues dear to my heart. The Rome Statute created more than a court; it created the outline for a system of justice for horrific crimes rooted first in national courts doing their job, and where they fail to do so, the ICC stepping in only as “the court of the last resort””.
The president said “the ICC also needs increased cooperation and financial resources from its member states”, adding that “State parties should express their commitment to increasing efforts in these areas, including pledging concrete assistance. The twenty years of the Court’s existence have witnessed several challenges, some of which had threatened the very existence of the Court itself.”
Calling on all states “not to politicize the decisions of the Court but to always bear in mind the rationale for the establishment of the Court in the first place, President Buhari urged “all States that have not yet done so to, as a matter of deliberate State policy, accede to the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court so that it can become a universal treaty.”
Buhari’s invitation has however infuriated many rights groups across the world who argue that an invitation to someone who has over 130 petitions against him at the ICC, whose current President, Chile Eboe-Osuji is a Nigerian, flies in the face of the integrity of the court.
A petition sent to the court’s Chief Prosecutor, Fatou Bensouda by the US Nigeria Law Group said that the invitation to Buhari to deliver a keynote address is “highly unusual, suspicious, unbecoming and troubling.”
The group said, “It is deeply inappropriate for any political actor, more so one who is potentially a person of interest in crimes currently under the purview of the ICC’s jurisdiction to brazenly claim to “use” the platform of the court in adulatory self promotion as a supposed African anti-corruption champion. No court or prosecutor should ever lend itself as a tool for such grandstanding.”
“While we agree that the government of Nigeria as represented by General Buhari should not be a priori denied reasonable access, such access must be limited to providing information related to crimes of interest to the Prosecutor based on knowledge available to them pursuant to Article 15. We respectfully submit that such reasonable access does not include socializing with court judges, nebulous “bilateral meetings” and a key note address unrelated to the specific subject matter jurisdiction of the court”, the petition signed by its Managing Partner, Emmanuel Ogebe said.
Full Text of President Muhammadu Buhari’s Speech at the International Criminal Court (ICC), The Hague, Netherlands.
Protocols:
I am honoured to be with you here today to celebrate the anniversary of this vital global institution. I say “vital” because the world needs the ICC.
Let me start by congratulating you, Judge Chile Eboe-Osuji, on your election as President of the International Criminal Court, and also thank the judges of the Court for electing you, a cherished son of Nigeria. Nigeria is very proud of you, Mr. President. Let me also express my gratitude to the International Criminal Court for inviting me to speak on this occasion.
As we know, the International Criminal Court was established twenty years ago as a global court, inspired by the Nuremberg trials of World War II war criminals, to hold people accountable for crimes against humanity, war crimes, crimes of genocide and aggression. In addition to preventing impunity, promoting adherence and respect for the rule of law and fundamental freedoms worldwide and to punishing those in leadership positions responsible for the most appalling crimes and atrocities, the ICC has given hope for justice to so many, by demanding strict adherence to the rules of international humanitarian law.
With the alarming proliferation of the most serious crimes around the world, the ICC, and all that it stands for, is now needed more than ever, in ways that were unforeseeable to its founders. The ICC may have been created at a time of optimism that it would not need to be utilized frequently, but, unfortunately, the increase in international crimes has only increased the Court’s relevance.
Indeed, while limits on the ICC’s jurisdiction mean that it cannot presently act with regard to some of the dire crises of the day in states that are not parties, by acting where it can, the ICC reinforces the demand for justice far beyond its own cases. A strong and effective ICC has the potential to send a powerful message about the international community’s commitment to accountability, a message that will be heard by both victims and perpetrators. Equally, a strong and effective ICC demonstrates the international community’s commitment to the rule of law.
A strong and effective ICC can also act as a catalyst for other justice efforts, expanding the reach of accountability. These could include serious cases of corruption by state actors that severely compromise the development efforts of countries and throw citizens into greater poverty. These could also include cases of illicit financial flows where countries are complicit and obstruct repatriation of stolen assets. As the African Union Champion on Anti-corruption, these are issues dear to my heart. The Rome Statute created more than a court; it created the outline for a system of justice for horrific crimes rooted first in national courts doing their job, and where they fail to do so, the ICC stepping in only as “the court of the last resort”
The ICC also needs increased cooperation and financial resources from its member states. State parties should express their commitment to increasing efforts in these areas, including pledging concrete assistance. The twenty years of the Court’s existence have witnessed several challenges, some of which had threatened the very existence of the Court itself. Most notable were the withdrawals and threats of withdrawals of membership of the Court by some States, as well as accusations of bias in the exercise of the jurisdiction of the Court. Thankfully, the Court has addressed these challenges in a dignified and commendable way.
Nonetheless, the Court needs to take on board all constructive criticisms and allay lingering fears and concern through targeted messaging, awareness raising and possible modification of some legal provisions. If properly articulated, communication and awareness raising would surely engender trust and encourage greater cooperation of Member States with the Court and even encourage non – Member States to decide to become Members. It must avoid even a hint of bias or political motivations.
The goals and responsibilities of the Court are no doubt very challenging and daunting but with the cooperation of all, coupled with the high caliber of Judges and staff of the Court, the challenges are not insurmountable. I therefore urge all States not to politicize the decisions of the Court but to always bear in mind the rationale for the establishment of the Court in the first place.
I urge all States that have not yet done so to, as a matter of deliberate State policy, accede to the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court so that it can become a universal treaty. Nigeria has cooperated with, and supported the Court at all times. This, we have demonstrated by our full and transparent cooperation on matters on which we are being investigated and also in our several Country statements at the sessions of the Court. Our cooperation with the Court is borne out of our strong belief in the respect for the rule of law and human rights, and in our firm commitment to the sanctity of fundamental freedoms at international and domestic levels, as ingrained in the objectives for establishing the Court.
In conclusion, let me intimate you that Nigeria is preparing to conduct general elections in 2019. Contrary to the tragic incidents that characterized the 2011 general elections in Nigeria which necessitated preliminary investigations by the International Criminal Court, I assure you that all hands are on deck to prevent any recurrence of such tragic incidents. We shall do everything possible to ensure that Nigeria witnesses the conduct of free, fair and peaceful elections in 2019.
Again, I congratulate the Court on its 20th Anniversary and wish it continued growth, relevance and success in the years to come in its vital role as a bulwark against man’s inhumanity to man.
Thank you for your attention.
Leave a Comment
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *